Immigration Practice News

June 2012 (Volume 3, Issue 4)

Issue link:

Contents of this Issue


Page 2 of 5

Crime Without Punishment: How Should a Client Answer? Tips for the Ethically-Minded Lawyer on How to Handle Potential Past Criminality on Immigration Forms by Cyrus D. Mehta A criminality can pose a dilemma for the ethically-minded immigration attorney and the processes raises a multitude of complex issues cutting across various areas of law. For example, the Form N-400, Application for Naturalization, asks broadly "Have you ever committed a crime or offense for which you have not been arrested?" One would be hard pressed to find a person who has never committed an offense for which she has not been arrested. Multitudes of New Yorkers must have committed the offense of jay walking within full sight of a police officer who never bothered citing the offender. Some states criminalize "fornication" (sexual intercourse between unmarried persons) despite this type of law's dubious constitutionality. New York criminalizes adultery no matter how long ago a person separated from the dvising a client on how to answer questions on immigration forms regarding potential past spouse. Does an immigration attorney have to plumb a client' answer the question-400? Must the lawyer then also report the client' s sexual past to past potential offenses such as speeding? s other The question on the I-485 application asks more narrowly if one has knowingly "committed any crime of moral turpitude ["CIMT"] or drug- related offense" which did not result in arrest. Given the heavy litigation in this area, only a lawyer with experience in this arena could recognize a CIMT. Under the categorical approach, which requires consideration of the minimal conduct implicated by a penal law, even if one has engaged in "theſt", a temporary taking of another's belongings (rather than a permanent one) may not be morally turpitudinous. See e.g. Wala v. Mukasey, 511 F.3d 102 (2d Cir. 2007). Regarding a "drug- "The question of knowingly committing a crime for which one has never been arrested derives from INA § 212(a)(2), which makes inadmissible one who admits having committed certain crimes." related offense," if your client smoked pot at a concert during college, how do you assess whether the act was a crime within that jurisdiction back then? In a complex penal law system, requiring the prosecutor to determine applicable law and demonstrating each element of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, without a lab test can the client know beyond a reasonable doubt that the substance was pot and not say oregano? ABA Model Rule 3.3(a)(1) states that "[a] lawyer shall not knowingly make a false statement of fact or law to a tribunal or fail to correct a false statement of a material fact or law previously made to the tribunal by the lawyer.." Criminal penalties may attach to a lawyer who knowingly falsely prepares an application for a client. See 18 USC 1001, 18 USC 1546 or 18 USC 371. Whether a lawyer can be accused of unethical or criminal conduct without knowing that a crime occurred is unclear; an overzealous prosecutor or bar investigator might pursue it. The question of knowingly committing a crime for which one has never been arrested derives from INA § 212(a) (2), which makes inadmissible one who admits having committed certain crimes. A non-citizen, including an LPR, need only have admitted to the commission of a crime to be ensnared, unless the admission is obtained in violation of the BIA' for obtaining a valid admission. See Matter of K-, 7 I&N Dec. 594 (BIA 1957). s stringent protocol The requirements established by the BIA to corral the unwieldy question suggests that it defies a straightforward answer. Even in what seems an obvious admission of crime—your client arrives to sign the form and reports having just killed someone, might she have committed an act of self-defense if she was in a city with a Stand Your Ground law? Cyrus D Mehta is the incoming Chair of AILA's Ethics Committee for 2012-13. He thanks his associate, Myriam Jaidi, for assistance on this article. 3

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Immigration Practice News - June 2012 (Volume 3, Issue 4)